Comments on: The Doctor and Sarah Jane Smith ride again! http://geektyrant.com/2009/05/the-doctor-12/ Geek Movie and Entertainment News Sat, 21 Nov 2009 15:11:25 -0700 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.5 hourly 1 By: Kirrilee http://geektyrant.com/2009/05/the-doctor-12/comment-page-1/#comment-8897 Kirrilee Wed, 27 May 2009 09:59:26 +0000 http://geektyrant.com/?p=6854#comment-8897 As much as I love David Tennant (and I do... I really do) I don't like the idea of him being on SJA... It's a small show, which will get ratings for the two episodes he's in and then everyone will turn around and bash it saying there should be more David. He just CAN'T do too much in it. It's a spin off, and yea often spin-off's feature guest appearances, but seriously? It's a kids show. And it's David Tennant. AND it's Sarah Jane's time to shine, and I really don't like the idea of this.... I know the Ten fans will shoot me down but I just can't accept this. I love SJA, but I'm not impressed. As far as Matt Smith is concerned, I love him in other things, but I'm reserving judgment as for how he will be as The Doctor (although I do hold high hopes for him). A movie? I wouldn't like it even if it was Tennant. Ok, yes I would see it, it's in my nature for these things, but It's a TV SHOW! It's meant to be like that. The Paul McGann movie in 1996/97 was great yea, but it wasn't made into an incredibly big deal as this will be. I'm glad Dr Who has this whole new fan base but this sort of catering to it really isn't doing it for me. I'm probably the only person who is annoyed at this but hey, I can have my say right? As much as I love David Tennant (and I do… I really do) I don't like the idea of him being on SJA… It's a small show, which will get ratings for the two episodes he's in and then everyone will turn around and bash it saying there should be more David. He just CAN'T do too much in it. It's a spin off, and yea often spin-off's feature guest appearances, but seriously? It's a kids show. And it's David Tennant. AND it's Sarah Jane's time to shine, and I really don't like the idea of this….

I know the Ten fans will shoot me down but I just can't accept this. I love SJA, but I'm not impressed.

As far as Matt Smith is concerned, I love him in other things, but I'm reserving judgment as for how he will be as The Doctor (although I do hold high hopes for him). A movie? I wouldn't like it even if it was Tennant. Ok, yes I would see it, it's in my nature for these things, but It's a TV SHOW! It's meant to be like that. The Paul McGann movie in 1996/97 was great yea, but it wasn't made into an incredibly big deal as this will be.

I'm glad Dr Who has this whole new fan base but this sort of catering to it really isn't doing it for me. I'm probably the only person who is annoyed at this but hey, I can have my say right?

]]> By: Chelle http://geektyrant.com/2009/05/the-doctor-12/comment-page-1/#comment-8828 Chelle Tue, 26 May 2009 23:37:44 +0000 http://geektyrant.com/?p=6854#comment-8828 Is it just me, or is the font in this article itty bitty? Sorry to nitpick! I presume that the show David Tennant will be appearing in is the Sarah Jane Adventures? I don't normally watch it, but for an extra Doctor fix i would most certainly tune in. As for a movie, i refuse to judge what kind of Doctor Matt Smith is going to be until i get to see him myself, and give him some time to grow into the role a little, i cried when Christopher Eccleston left the Whoverse and was mad at David Tennant for about 15 (whole) minutes before i got over it and fell in love with him, I'm more than willing to give Matt Smith this same chance :) Is it just me, or is the font in this article itty bitty? Sorry to nitpick!

I presume that the show David Tennant will be appearing in is the Sarah Jane Adventures? I don't normally watch it, but for an extra Doctor fix i would most certainly tune in.

As for a movie, i refuse to judge what kind of Doctor Matt Smith is going to be until i get to see him myself, and give him some time to grow into the role a little, i cried when Christopher Eccleston left the Whoverse and was mad at David Tennant for about 15 (whole) minutes before i got over it and fell in love with him, I'm more than willing to give Matt Smith this same chance :)

]]> By: spcglider http://geektyrant.com/2009/05/the-doctor-12/comment-page-1/#comment-8777 spcglider Tue, 26 May 2009 20:24:29 +0000 http://geektyrant.com/?p=6854#comment-8777 Oh... Sarah Jane. Your smile, your eyes, your Andy Pandy overalls... That's superb! I knew David Tennant was a classy enough guy to not just abandon the franchise. In fact, imagine this: TWO Doctors functioning simultaneously in different series? What are the possibilities? Oh… Sarah Jane. Your smile, your eyes, your Andy Pandy overalls…

That's superb! I knew David Tennant was a classy enough guy to not just abandon the franchise.

In fact, imagine this: TWO Doctors functioning simultaneously in different series? What are the possibilities?

]]>