Johnny Depp's Bizarre PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN Performance Initially Scared the Hell Out of Disney Executives

Imagine spending millions of dollars on a pirate movie, watching the first footage roll in, and wondering if your leading man has completely lost his mind.

That's pretty much the situation some Disney executives found themselves in when Johnny Depp showed up as Captain Jack Sparrow in Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl.

Today, Jack Sparrow is one of the most recognizable and most fun movie characters ever created, but back in 2002, Disney wasn't entirely sure what the hell Depp was doing.

It's hard to imagine Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl without Captain Jack Sparrow's drunken swagger, slurred speech, and wonderfully strange personality. That performance helped turn a risky Disney movie into a billion-dollar franchise, but the studio wasn't exactly celebrating when the first footage arrived.

During a panel at the FilmQuest Film Festival, former Disney executive and producer Brigham Taylor shared how Depp's interpretation of Jack Sparrow initially caught people at Disney completely off guard.

Taylor had helped develop Pirates of the Caribbean alongside colleagues Josh Harmon and Michael Haynes. Their goal was to make the kind of adventure movie they felt Disney had stopped making.

Taylor said: "We imagined something inspired by Spielberg and Lucas: a big, four-quadrant adventure that could appeal to everyone."

That ambition eventually became Pirates of the Caribbean, with Jerry Bruckheimer producing and Gore Verbinski directing. But while the filmmakers were building a supernatural adventure filled with cursed pirates and elaborate action sequences, Depp had his own ideas about what kind of hero should be leading the charge.

According to Taylor, Depp hadn't auditioned or given Disney executives a clear preview of how he planned to play Jack Sparrow. He developed the character himself, arrived on set, and unleashed a performance nobody was quite prepared for.

What nobody at Disney fully anticipated was the version of Jack Sparrow that Depp had cooked up. Taylor recalled being in Vancouver visiting the production of The Santa Clause 2 when Haynes called after watching the first Pirates dailies.

Haynes was concerned about Depp's performance and compared it to Dudley Moore's drunken character in Arthur. That's the kind of phone call that will give you lots of anxiety when your studio has millions riding on a pirate movie.

Depp hadn't auditioned or demonstrated the full extent of his interpretation before filming. He arrived with a character that was far stranger than the conventional Hollywood action hero, and some executives weren't sure audiences would go along with it.

There were discussions about whether Depp should tone down the performance. Taylor, however, wasn't nearly as worried.

When asked if you could tell if a movie was going to be a hit or a flop, Brigham said: “Sometimes you don't realize there's a serious problem until it's far too late to stop the train. Even with experience, you can be completely wrong.

Take the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie. Nobody really knew what Johnny Depp was going to do with his performance. When people first saw it, some were genuinely freaked out. They were asking, ‘How drunk is he going to be?’

“I remember being in Vancouver visiting the set of The Santa Clause 2. I'd been on the first day of shooting for Pirates, but then I had to leave. Back then, we were shooting on film, so it took a couple of days to see the footage.

“My colleague Michael called me after watching the first dailies. He was worried. He compared Johnny's performance to Dudley Moore in Arthur. Essentially, he was saying, ‘This guy looks drunk.’ And that was a surprise because Johnny hadn't necessarily revealed the full extent of what he planned to do.

“He didn't have to audition or put himself on tape. He'd made these creative decisions internally, and then he showed up and performed the character. Some people thought it might ruin the movie. There were conversations about whether he could pull it back.

“But we'd already spent tens of millions of dollars. The train was moving. Personally, I wasn't as worried as some of the other people involved, And, of course, that performance became one of the most memorable of Johnny's career.

That's the thing. You don't know. You start with your best instincts and a theory about why the movie should work. You try to protect that idea throughout development and production. But things can change at any point. Weather can affect you. An actor can leave. A performance can turn out differently than expected. Or something completely outside your control can happen.”

Depp's choices were part of what made Jack Sparrow unlike anything audiences had seen in a Disney adventure.

When Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl opened in 2003, it earned more than $650 million worldwide. Depp received an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor, and Captain Jack Sparrow became the character audiences couldn't get enough of.

The performance that initially made Disney nervous became the franchise's biggest selling point. Taylor and his colleagues had set out to bring some excitement back to Disney's live-action movies, and they certainly got their wish.

As Taylor put it while reflecting on the film's success: "I think it proved that Disney could still make movies that were relevant to a much broader audience. That was exactly what we'd hoped to accomplish."

GeekTyrant Homepage