EBENEZER Review: A Creepy, Gothy, Wildly Fun Christmas Carol That Deserves More Love

I know Ebenezer has been catching a sleigh full of Bah humbug reactions, and yeah, I’ve seen the complaints about Johnny Depp’s performance as Ebenezer Scrooge. But I enjoyed this movie!

This is the kind of fun, spooky, theatrical Christmas movie that takes Charles Dickens’ classic ghost story back into the foggy Victorian streets where it belongs, drenches it in gothic horror flavor, and gleefully reminds us that Christmas can be creepy too.

As someone who loves A Christmas Carol in just about every form, I walked away from this one feeling like Ti West knew exactly what makes this story work, then cranked up the ghosts, the gloom, and the gothic weirdness in all the right ways.

Depp’s Scrooge worked for me. He gives exactly the kind of Johnny Depp performance I expected. It’s cartoonish, strange, cranky, twitchy, theatrical, and full of that oddball energy he’s known for.

Some people are calling it too much, but come on, this is Ebenezer Scrooge! The guy is basically Christmas misery stuffed into a waistcoat. Depp leans into the exaggerated miser routine, snarling through his days, tormenting poor Bob Cratchit, played by Rupert Grint, and brushing off his kindhearted nephew Fred, played by Sam Claflin, like holiday cheer is an infectious disease.

Then, as the ghosts start ripping open his past, present, and future, the performance shifts into something warmer and more wounded without losing that wonderfully weird edge.

What I really loved is how West brings the spooky back into the story. A Christmas Carol gets treated like a cozy holiday redemption tale so often that people forget it’s also about a dead business partner dragging chains into a man’s bedroom and three spirits psychologically body-slamming him into becoming a better person. Ebenezer embraces that.

The fog-drenched Victorian London looks grimy, rich, and miserable in all the right ways, with poverty and greed sitting right next to each other like two rotten Christmas puddings.

The 35mm-style look gives it this old-school horror texture, and the Hammer Horror influence is all over the movie’s bones. It’s stylish without feeling like it’s trying too hard, and the production design gives the whole thing a haunted storybook vibe.

The ghosts are where the movie really cooks. Ian McKellen as Jacob Marley is exactly the kind of spectral warning bell this story needs, full of dread, regret, and chain-rattling doom.

Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past is wonderfully unsettling, almost corpse-like, drifting through Scrooge’s memories like some nightmare he can’t wake up from.

Then Tramell Tillman comes in as the Ghost of Christmas Present and brings this great burst of warmth and life to the movie. His energy helps keep the film from getting swallowed whole by its shadows.

The spirits are creepy, unsettling, and memorable, and I loved the designs West gives them. They are supernatural forces with personality.

For all its moody shadows, eerie visitations, and deliciously grim atmosphere, Ebenezer doesn’t forget the heart. That’s the part that really made it click for me.

Scrooge confronting the loss of his sister, his heartbreak with Belle, the struggles of the Cratchit family, and the possible fate of Tiny Tim still hits. The movie has teeth, but it also has soul.

It understands that the horror of the story isn’t only in the ghosts, it’s in wasted time, selfishness, loneliness, and the awful realization that you’ve made your life smaller than it ever needed to be.

That emotional punch sneaks up through all the gothic style, and by the time Scrooge wakes up on Christmas morning ready to change, I was fully onboard.

So no, I’m not joining the cranky critic carolers trashing this thing. Ebenezer is a creepy, visually gorgeous, energetic, and surprisingly heartfelt take on one of the greatest Christmas stories ever written.

It’s weird in the right ways, spooky in the right places, and full of enough holiday ghost madness to make it stand apart from the usual seasonal lineup.

Don’t let the naysayers scare you off. If you’re a fan of A Christmas Carol, gothic horror, Johnny Depp doing his eccentric thing, or Christmas movies with a sinister little grin, this one is absolutely worth unwrapping.

GeekTyrant Homepage