George R.R. Martin Reviews ANT-MAN, Knocks Marvel Villains

While there are certainly hardcore readers out there who want author George R.R. Martin to be doing nothing but writing the next book in his A Song of Ice and Fire series, he's choosing live his life on his own terms. He recently took some time to see Marvel's Ant-Man, and he went to his LiveJournal page to provide some context for his relationship to the comics and write his own review. I won't reprint the entire thing here, but I thought there were a few notable elements people may find interesting:

Scott Lang is the featured Ant-Man, yes, and Paul Rudd makes him a sympathetic and engaging protagonist, but due honor is done to Hank and his own career as the first Ant-Man as well, with Michael Douglas turning in a fine performance as Pym. There's a lot of humor in this film, but it is not a farce, as I feared it might be. There's a lot of action too, but not so much that it overwhelms the plot and characters, which was my problem with the last AVENGERS film... and the one before it, to think of it. A superhero movie needs a fair share of smashing and bashing and stuff blowing up, of course, but IMNSHO that stuff works best when it is happening to people we actually know and care about, and if you jam in too many characters and don't take time to develop any of them properly, well...

ANT-MAN has a proper balance of story, character, humor, and action, I think. A couple reviewers are calling it the best Marvel movie ever. I won't go that far, but it's right up there, maybe second only to the second Sam Raimi/ Tobey McGuire Spider-Man film, the one with Doc Ock. I've liked most of the Marvel movies, to be sure, I'm still a Marvel fanboy at heart (Excelsior!), but I liked this one more than the first AVENGERS and a lot more than the second, more than either THOR, more than the second and third IRON MAN and maybe just a smidge more than the first (though I liked that one a lot too).

I wouldn't rank Ant-Man nearly that high in my own personal rankings of the Marvel films, but then again Martin is taking Sony's Spider-Man films into consideration, so that opens things up to a whole different level of comparison.

But perhaps the most interesting aspect of his review is the section in which he calls out Marvel for having a villain problem:

Quibbles? Yeah, a few. Where was the Wasp? We got a few glimpses, and a set up for the next film. But I wanted more Wasp, and I loved the old original Hank/ Janet dynamic (before they got to the wife-beating stuff). Also, while Yellowjacket makes a decent villain here (in the comics, of course, he was actually one of Hank's later identities, after Giant-Man and Goliath), I am tired of this Marvel movie trope where the bad guy has the same powers as the hero. The Hulk fought the Abomination, who is just a bad Hulk. Spider-Man fights Venom, who is just a bad Spider-Man. Iron Man fights Ironmonger, a bad Iron Man. Yawn. I want more films where the hero and the villain have wildly different powers. That makes the action much more interesting).

I'm right there with him on wanting more Wasp, and I also thought Darren Cross was a pretty worthless villain. Calling out the reflective powers of the villains is not a groundbreaking observation, but that doesn't make it any less true; while Marvel Studios has been able to have the occasional villain be memorable or interesting with this formula (Loki and Ultron come to mind), it's mostly resulted in boring, eye-rolling depictions of bad guys.

What do you think? You can read more of Martin's thoughts about the movie here.

GeekTyrant Homepage