HBO’s HARRY POTTER Series Snape Casting Sparks Debate; Fans Point Out How It Alters Key Dynamics in The Story
HBO’s upcoming Harry Potter series has been making headlines recently with its casting choices, but the latest reported addition has set off a wave of debate among fans.
HBO is close to finalizing a deal with Paapa Essiedu (The Lazarus Project) to take on the role of Severus Snape. While any major casting in this franchise was bound to generate conversation, this one has sparked an interesting discussion among fans about how this decision could fundamentally alter key dynamics in the story.
Over on the Harry Potter HBO Reddit page, the reaction was immediate. The casting report also mentioned that Janet McTeer is in talks to play Professor Minerva McGonagall, but the discussion zeroed in on Snape, racking up over 1,200 comments.
The top-voted comment earned over 1,500 upvotes and even was given the Reddit Gold treatment. It expressed a concern that has resonated with fans. It reads:
“My concern with Paapa’s casting is that it changes the whole dynamic with Snape. James and Sirius immediately disliked him – and now that has a different connotation.
“Harry also immediately dislikes and distrusts Snape. And now that also has a different connotation. Lilly rejected her childhood BFF in favor of dating James. And now that also has a different connotation.”
This comment gained nearly four times more upvotes than any other response, so it’s clear that many fans see this as a potential issue. The discussion also spilled onto X and TikTok, with similar sentiments.
“I didn’t even think about it like that. Yikes,” one user responded. Another agreed, adding, “This is well put, I agree.” And then there was the inevitable plea: “Please don’t give people reasons to be outraged. Not a good look.”
It’s worth noting that casting a talented actor in a role shouldn’t inherently be a problem, but the concern here isn’t about performance. It’s about how the choice may unintentionally shift the meaning behind key character interactions.
Snape’s history with James Potter, Sirius Black, and Lily Evans is central to Harry Potter’s backstory, and many fans feel this casting introduces a new layer of interpretation that the show’s writers will have to navigate carefully.
What are your thoughts on Paapa Essiedu being cast in the role of Snape? Do you think it will cause some issues with the story?