Sony Boss Wants SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Nominated for Best Picture: "Are There 10 Films That Are Better?"

Hollywood loves handing out Oscars to serious dramas, but Sony Pictures boss Tom Rothman thinks it's time the Academy gave Spider-Man some damn respect.

He's pushing for Spider-Man: Brand New Day to land a Best Picture nomination at the 99th Academy Awards, and he's got a pretty simple argument: Name 10 movies from 2026 that were actually better.

Rothman, chairman and CEO of Sony Pictures, made his case during an interview with Deadline, arguing that the Academy needs to recognize great filmmaking even when it comes wrapped in a superhero costume.

"The Academy is meant to recognize greatness. But also to receive wisdom about what greatness is. We’re gonna do what we can just to make people think about it.

“I think it’s also incumbent upon studios who make these kinds of quality commercial films to get people to think about it, and here’s what I ask people when I walk around: 'Are you telling me that there are 10 films this year that are better than this film?'"

It's a fair question, especially considering what Tom Holland and the creative team accomplished with the fourth Spider-Man movie.

Brand New Day didn't just dominate the box office. It became the highest-grossing movie in domestic box office history, surpassing Star Wars: The Force Awakens. That's a ridiculous achievement, but Rothman believes the film deserves recognition for something beyond selling a mountain of tickets.

At its heart, Brand New Day tackles loneliness, emotional isolation, and the struggles young adults face trying to connect with other people. Rather than building toward another massive CGI slugfest, the movie takes a surprisingly personal approach to its finale.

"I think Academy members would be interested in this because it’s very significant from a storytelling movie. This is really the first of these kinds of movies that I can think of that does not climax in a giant battle.

“In this movie, there is no giant action sequence at the end. The climax of this movie is two young people sitting on the edge of a bed, talking to each other and sharing their deepest pain. This movie is melancholy in that way and beautiful."

Of course, the Academy's relationship with comic book movies has been pretty frustrating over the years. Heath Ledger won Best Supporting Actor for The Dark Knight, while Joaquin Phoenix took home Best Actor for Joker. But no full-fledged comic book superhero movie has ever won Best Picture.

Spider-Man's own Oscar history isn't particularly impressive either. Several live-action installments have earned nominations for visual effects and sound, but Spider-Man 2 remains the franchise's only Oscar winner, taking home Best Visual Effects in 2005.

Sony wants to change that with a serious Best Picture campaign for Brand New Day. The Academy's expanded Best Picture field, which has featured 10 nominees since 2021, could help its chances. More available spots should mean more opportunities for different kinds of movies to compete, including massive crowd-pleasers that don't fit the usual awards-season mold.

Rothman also argues that making an exceptional commercial movie deserves just as much respect as making an acclaimed prestige drama.

"Wise heads know that quality commercial filmmaking is extremely difficult," he pointed out, before asking again, "are there 10 films that are better than this film, just in pure quality?"

Look, box office records don't automatically make a movie Oscar-worthy. But neither should a superhero costume automatically disqualify one from the conversation.

Spider-Man: Brand New Day does deliver the kind of emotional storytelling Rothman is championing, so there's no reason it shouldn't compete against Hollywood's usual awards contenders.

Whether Academy voters agree is another matter entirely. Sony is clearly ready to fight for its friendly neighborhood Spider-Man, and watching a comic book blockbuster crash Hollywood's biggest awards party could be a lot of fun.

What do you think? Does Spider-Man: Brand New Day deserve a Best Picture nomination?

GeekTyrant Homepage