WD 1TB SSD Review: The Results Were Surprising

The further we get into the eighth generation of gaming, the larger games seem to get. Back in 2013, when the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One originally launched, they included relatively small 500 GB hard drives that could be filled up with just a few games. Since then, new models of each console have been released that include more storage, but load times have been an ever-increasing problem.

With the rise of 4K gaming looming upon us and the increasing size of game installs and load times, gamers are looking for ways to get better performance out of their consoles. Our friends at Western Digital have provided us with two such options to test for you, a 1 TB WD Blue Solid State Hybrid Drive and a 1 TB WD Blue Solid State Drive. 

Specs & Comparison

While these drives would primarily be used as a replacement for the PS4’s internal hard drive, they can also be used externally on both the PS4 and Xbox One with the use of a Sata to USB 3.0 adapter. I will be testing out both drives, internally and externally, compared to the stock drives that come with a PS4 and Xbox One.  For these tests I will be using a few different games for each system and performing the noted loads four times and calculating the average time. As a note on the performance of Solid State Hybrid drives, they build up a cache of most used files into their Solid State partition to allow faster loading of that data. Each test involving the Hybrid drive is ran 8 times with the last four times being averaged.

Uncharted 4 (PS4)

Initial Load

Stock HDD                         WD Blue SSHD                WD Blue SSD

0:28                                    0:29                                   0:20

WD MyPassport (Ext)       WD Blue SSHD (Ext)       WD Blue SSD (Ext)

0:27                                    0:31                                   0:20

New Game Load

Stock HDD                       WD Blue SSHD                 WD Blue SSD 

0:35                                  0:42                                    0:34         

WD MyPassport (Ext)     WD Blue SSHD (Ext)        WD Blue SSD (Ext)        

0:38                                  0:35                                    0:34

Uncharted 4 provided interesting results. While the SSD was faster than the stock PS4 HDD, it wasn’t by a significant margin. Even stranger was that the SSHD ran slower than the stock HDD. Utilizing the USB 3.0 ports on the PS4 should also have theoretically provided better performance than the internal Sata 2 connection. Thankfully, the SSHD did perform better on USB than internally.

The Witcher 3 (PS4)

Loading a new game save

Stock HDD                            WD Blue SSHD                   WD Blue SSD

0:24                                       0:29                                     0:15

WD MyPassport (Ext)          WD Blue SSHD (Ext)          WD Blue SSD (Ext)

0:26                                       0:26                                      0:15

Once again we see the SSHD take a hit when it is used inside the PS4. The SSD however, chugs out the same performance regardless of how it is used.

Street Fighter V (PS4)

Loading a fight

Stock HDD                            WD Blue SSHD                   WD Blue SSD

0:18                                        0:15                                     0:14

WD MyPassport (Ext)          WD Blue SSHD (Ext)          WD Blue SSD (Ext)

0:17                                        0:33                                     0:14

Street Fighter V shows the results I was expecting to see from my two prior test games. Each drive lowers loads over that of the stock PS4 HDD. This is also the first test that had the SSHD perform better internally than over USB.

Halo 5 (Xbox One)

Initial Load

Stock HDD WD                        MyPassport (Ext)

0:45                                          0:41

WD Blue SSHD (Ext)              WD Blue SSD (Ext)

0:32                                          0:33

Level Load

Stock HDD                             WD MyPassport (Ext)

0:29                                         0:25

WD Blue SSHD (Ext)            WD Blue SSD (Ext)

0:18                                        0:14

Halo 5 outputs the exact results I would expect from a hard drive benchmark test. Hooking up any external drive instantly provides a slight performance boost and each tier only makes it quicker.

Rise of the Tomb Raider (Xbox One)

Initial Load

Stock HDD                             WD MyPassport (Ext)

0:28                                        0:27

WD Blue SSHD (Ext)            WD Blue SSD (Ext)

0:24                                        0:21

Save game load

Stock HDD                             WD MyPassport (Ext)

0:25                                        0:24

WD Blue SSHD (Ext)            WD Blue SSD (Ext)

0:12                                        0:17

Rise of the Tomb Raider also benefits from external storage. This time around the SSHD came out on top in the average times.

If you are determined to get the fastest loads no matter what for your console of choice, the WD Blue SSD won’t let you down. I personally can not recommend doing this for a console though.  With the high price of a higher capacity SSD, the minor performance gains just cant justify the expense.

Verdict

For gamers truly looking for a mix of price to performance, a WD Blue SSHD will be the best bet at a much more affordable cost. However, WD no longer carries these SATA SSHD's anymore, so you might consider getting the WD Blue Desktop SSHD and using the adapter for a similar result. Regardless of which option you choose, I would highly recommend running each drive off a SATA to USB adapter. Since performance is generally only improved over USB, this will save PS4 owners the trouble of having to reinstall their system OS.  It also allows each drive to be used on an Xbox One. What do you think of these results? Did any of them surprise you? Leave a comment below!

Amazon Affiliate Links: SATA-USB 3.0 Adapter , 1TB SSD , 1TB SSHD