Live-Action ALADDIN Comes Under Fire For "Browning Up" White Extras
As many of you already know, whitewashing is the practice of casting white people in non-white character roles. It’s very controversial and brings up a lot of unpleasant arguments. One recent example is Ghost in the Shell where several white actors were cast in place of Japanese or even Asian actors. There was plenty of backlash on that movie and others like it, and as always, there’s a typical explanation. Some say that they went with a specific actor because of talent, others try to explain that it doesn’t matter for the world of the movie, etc. Enter Disney.
Disney has been working very hard on their live-action version of Aladdin (I’m not sure why we need one, but according to the mouse house, we do) and they have been very careful about their casting choices. Marwan Kenzari is a Dutch-Tunisian actor who will play Jafar, Naomi Scott (yes, she was controversial for being British) will play Jasmine and her mom is of Indian descent, and Aladdin, Mena Massoud, was born in Egypt. Not to mention, according to Deadline, the film has 400 background performers who are Indian, Middle Eastern, African, Mediterranean, or Asian. So why are people upset? Apparently, Disney has hired 100 white people as extras they are “browning up” to make it appear they are Middle Eastern. I’m just surprised they need 500 extras and can’t reuse some of them. Disney responded to the criticism as such:
“Great care was taken to put together one of the largest most diverse casts ever seen on screen. Diversity of our cast and background performers was a requirement and only in a handful of instances when it was a matter of specialty skills, safety and control (special effects rigs, stunt performers and handling of animals) were crew made up to blend in.”
Some of Disney’s critics say that this kind of casting is lazy and discounts the lives of non-whites. Actor Kal Penn criticized Disney in this tweet:
Are you excited about this film? What are your thoughts on “browning up” 100 extras?